Well yeah the Narnia director didn't work for me as far as adapting the Narnia books goes (in fact he worked so badly I refuse to see any more adaptions of these books from the current vein. But I could completely see how that style might work in for the Captain America movie.

But it was mostly about the writers.
The writing on October sky and Rocketeer IMHO fits better with what I'd want in a Cap movie than the writing for Narnia :(