Well, Katie Holmes carried a lot of blame for Batman Begins/Dark Knight which I don't feel she deserved - what did she have to work with, really? She was just extraneous to the plot, and it showed. Jessica Alba got it in the neck for FF, Jennifer Garner got a lot of criticism for Daredevil, Malin Ackerman was reamed for Watchmen. Hell, there's already a post over at noscans_daily saying Hit Girl is the weak point of Kick Ass. I'm not saying it's inevitable, but it happens a heck of a lot.

Michelle Pfeiffer was awesome in Batman Returns, and that's because they actually gave her material to work with. (Okay, and Michelle Pfeiffer is awesome.)